Reviewed · ORKNEY & SHETLAND TOURS
Orkney Mainland Private Tour
Orkney packs centuries into one day. This private seven-hour outing links the Italian Chapel, Scapa Flow, ancient stone circles, Skara Brae, and Brough of Birsay in one well-planned route. I like the chance to travel in a quiet luxury electric vehicle, and I like having Paul, the guide, available for questions and local stories throughout the day. The main drawback is the full schedule, especially when tides affect access to Brough of Birsay.
You pay $322.21 per person, so this is not a budget sightseeing bus. Still, the cost includes the two stated entrance fees, private transport, and a guide for your own group. You also need to budget about $10 to $20 for lunch, and the strict non-refundable booking policy makes an early, careful decision important.
In This Review
- Key points to know before booking
- Why this private Orkney route works
- The Italian Chapel and the story of Scapa Flow
- Stenness and the Ring of Brodgar
- Skara Brae, the day’s main archaeological visit
- Brough of Birsay and the tide timetable
- The drive between sites is part of the experience
- Lunch, pickup, and the practical details
- What makes Paul’s guiding important
- Is $322.21 per person good value?
- Who should book this Orkney day?
- Should you book the Orkney Mainland Private Tour?
- FAQ
- How long does the Orkney Mainland Private Tour last?
- Where does the tour start and end?
- Is pickup available from other locations?
- Is lunch included?
- Is admission to Skara Brae included?
- Is the Italian Chapel entrance included?
- Can I visit Brough of Birsay at any time?
Key points to know before booking

- Paul’s personal guiding style: He mixes local culture and personal stories with the major archaeological sites, and past guests especially praised his friendly, engaging manner.
- Seven major stops in seven hours: The route covers the Italian Chapel, Scapa Flow, Stenness, the Ring of Brodgar, Skara Brae, Brough of Birsay, and the roads between them.
- Skara Brae admission is included: You get the presentations, reconstructed Neolithic house, and guided walk without paying the separate £12 entrance fee.
- Brough of Birsay depends on the tide: You cross its causeway only at low tide, so the exact order and timing may change.
- Private transport makes the day flexible: Only your group joins the activity, with pickup possible at the Kirkwall Hotel or many other places on Orkney Mainland.
- Lunch is separate: The tour allows time to stop at a local eatery, but food is not part of the price.
Why this private Orkney route works
Orkney is not a place where one famous sight tells the whole story. Its appeal comes from the way sea power, wartime memories, early Christianity, Viking settlement, and Neolithic life sit close together. This tour gives you a broad look at that story without making you arrange several separate visits.
The private format matters. You are not joining a large coach group, and only your party takes part. That gives Paul room to answer questions as they come up, adjust the pace within the available seven hours, and talk about the places in a more personal way.
You will spend a fair amount of time in the vehicle. That is not wasted time here. The roads connect scattered sites, and the drive offers open views across Orkney while Paul fills in the gaps. The luxury electric vehicle should make those transfers quieter and more comfortable than a basic minibus, though the long list of stops means this is still an active sightseeing day rather than a slow, leisurely outing.
More Orkney and Shetland trips:
- Orkney Day Trip
★ 5.0 · 142 reviews - 5-Day Orkney & Northern Coast Tour from Edinburgh Incl Admissions
★ 5.0 · 132 reviews - Orkney West Mainland Tour
★ 5.0 · 131 reviews
The Italian Chapel and the story of Scapa Flow

The Italian Chapel is a small building with a surprisingly ornate interior. Italian prisoners of war built it during the Second World War, and the guided visit gives the chapel more meaning than a quick photograph from outside.
You have about 30 minutes here, with admission included. That is enough for a focused visit, but not enough for lingering over every detail. I would pay attention to the contrast between the chapel’s modest origins and its highly decorated finish. It is one of the day’s most human stops, since the building reflects skill, faith, and effort under difficult conditions.
The tour then takes a panoramic route around Scapa Flow, known to the Vikings as Skalpai Floi. This huge natural harbour mattered to Viking seafarers and later to the British during both world wars. The stop lasts about 30 minutes, so expect viewpoints and explanation rather than a long walk or a museum visit.
Scapa Flow is best understood from the road and from the water views around it. Paul’s role is useful here because the importance of a broad harbour is not always obvious at first glance. With context, the setting becomes easier to read as a place shaped by movement, defence, and access to the sea.
Stenness and the Ring of Brodgar

The Standing Stones of Stenness date to about 3100 BC. A guided walk around this henge site gives you a chance to see the stones at close range and understand their place within Orkney’s prehistoric monuments.
You get roughly 30 minutes here. Wear shoes suited to outdoor ground, since this is an open-air site rather than a polished indoor attraction. The short visit also means you should not expect a long archaeological lecture. The value is in seeing the monument directly, then letting the guide explain what makes it important.
The Ring of Brodgar receives a longer hour. This broad circle of Neolithic stones dates to about 3000 BC. Sixty stones originally formed the ring, with 27 still remaining today. That number helps you picture the scale of the original site, even though time and weather have changed it.
The Ring is also a good place to watch for curlews, oystercatchers, and skylarks. Birdlife adds another layer to the stop, but sightings are never guaranteed, so treat them as a bonus rather than a promised part of the tour. The open setting can feel exposed, too. Wind and weather may affect how long you want to stay outside.
Together, Stenness and Brodgar give you two different encounters with Orkney’s ancient stone culture. Stenness is shorter and more compact. Brodgar gives you room to look, walk, and take in the scale of the circle.
Skara Brae, the day’s main archaeological visit

Skara Brae is the longest scheduled stop at one hour and 30 minutes, and rightly so. Dating to about 3100 BC, this Neolithic village lets you look at the remains of stone-built homes rather than only isolated stones in a field.
The visit includes presentations, a mock-up of a Neolithic house, and a guided walk to and around the village. That combination is useful because it moves from explanation to reconstruction to the actual site. You are not left trying to work out the layout from low stone walls alone.
The Atlantic views add drama, but the setting also reminds you that this was a real settlement in a demanding coastal environment. I like that the visit gives you time to consider both the practical design of the houses and the wider setting. It is not just a quick photo stop on the way to somewhere else.
The £12 per-person entrance fee is included. That makes a noticeable difference to the value, especially if more than two people are in your group. The stop is still tightly fitted into a busy day, so you may want to keep your time moving between the presentations, mock-up, and village rather than lingering too long in one area.
A few more trips and experiences worth a look
- The Potter Trail Private Tour
★ 5.0 · 2,353 reviews - Isle of Skye Full Day Private Tour from Inverness
★ 5.0 · 1,065 reviews - Loch Ness & Culloden Battlefield Private Tour from Inverness
★ 5.0 · 932 reviews - Private Tour of the Scottish Highlands from Edinburgh
★ 5.0 · 325 reviews
Brough of Birsay and the tide timetable

Brough of Birsay brings a different period into the day. At low tide, you walk across the causeway to reach the island and see remains linked to Pictish and Viking settlement from the seventh through the 13th centuries.
The scheduled visit lasts about one hour. The causeway is the key practical issue. Access depends on tidal times, and the operator will advise you about the timing. If the tide does not allow a crossing during the available window, the plan may need to change.
That uncertainty is not a flaw in the tour. It is simply part of visiting a tidal site. Still, you should know that the final shape of the day may not be fixed in advance. The causeway walk and the island’s coastal views are major reasons to include Brough of Birsay, but you need to accept that nature controls the timetable.
The site also broadens the tour beyond the Neolithic period. After seeing 5,000-year-old monuments, you move into Pictish and Viking settlement. That range is one of the strongest features of the route.
The drive between sites is part of the experience

The tour allows about two hours for travel between locations. On a map, that can look like time lost. On Orkney Mainland, it is a chance to sit back and watch the scenery change between archaeological sites, coast, harbour, and open countryside.
The luxury electric vehicle should suit people who value a quieter, more comfortable ride. You also have Paul on hand during the transfers, so you can ask about the sites, Orkney life, or local culture instead of treating the road sections as dead time.
This is where the private format earns part of its price. A standard self-drive day would require you to study routes, monitor the tide for Brough of Birsay, find parking, manage entrance fees, and keep the clock moving. Here, those duties are handled for you. The tradeoff is that you give up some freedom to stop wherever you like, since six main sightseeing points already fill the day.
Lunch, pickup, and the practical details

Lunch is not included. The tour gives you time to stop somewhere local, with a typical meal costing about $10 to $20. Since the day includes outdoor sites and several hours on the road, I would use the meal break to eat properly rather than rely on a quick snack.
The stated starting point is Kirkwall Hotel, Kirkwall, KW15 1LE. The activity ends back at the meeting point. Pickup can also be arranged from many locations on Orkney Mainland, so ask about your exact accommodation before booking.
The tour operates from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Monday through Sunday, during the stated operating period from January 17, 2023, through March 9, 2027. Confirmation arrives at booking. Service animals are allowed, the activity is near public transportation, and most people can participate, though the outdoor walks and tidal causeway make comfortable footwear a sensible choice.
Gratuities are not included and remain your choice. Since Paul has received especially strong praise for his warmth, local stories, and ability to make a group feel at ease, you may want to allow for a tip if his guiding adds real value to your day.
What makes Paul’s guiding important

The sites would still be impressive without commentary, but the tour’s strongest personal feature is Paul. He has been praised for being personable, engaging, and able to explain local culture through personal stories. That style suits Orkney, where a short historical label cannot explain everything you are seeing.
You should expect a guide who is available for questions rather than someone delivering only a fixed script. One past group also added St. Magnus Cathedral to its day and appreciated Paul’s personal stories there. If that cathedral matters to you, ask about it before booking instead of assuming it is part of the standard route.
The praise for Paul is unusually consistent, with a 5 out of 5 overall rating from 40 reviews and 100 percent recommendation. That does not erase the practical limits of the schedule, but it does suggest that the human side of the tour is a major reason to choose it over driving yourself.
Is $322.21 per person good value?
At $322.21 per person, the tour costs more than simply renting a car and visiting a few sites independently. The comparison is not quite fair, though. Your price includes a private guide, transport for the full day, the Skara Brae admission of £12, and the Italian Chapel fee of £3.50.
The value improves for a group that wants comfort and a single person handling the route. It also improves if you are visiting Orkney for a short time and want to cover the main highlights without spending days planning connections and opening details.
The price is harder to justify if you prefer slow visits, long walks, or choosing only one or two sites. Seven hours is packed, and you will spend around two hours moving between places. Independent visitors who enjoy setting their own pace may find a self-planned day more satisfying.
For a family or small private group, the cost buys more than entrance tickets. It buys a day shaped around your group, a guide who can respond to your questions, and a comfortable vehicle on Orkney’s long connecting roads.
Who should book this Orkney day?
I would choose this tour if you want the major historic sites in one day and prefer not to drive. It fits first-time visitors, families, small groups, and anyone who values a personal guide over the lowest possible price.
It also suits people with a strong interest in archaeology. The route moves from Neolithic monuments to Pictish and Viking remains, then to wartime history at Scapa Flow and the Italian Chapel. That is a lot of time periods in one day, but the sequence gives you a useful sense of how Orkney’s story changed.
I would hesitate if you need a slow pace, dislike outdoor walking, or cannot accept a tide-dependent stop. You should also avoid booking casually, since the experience is non-refundable and cannot be changed after purchase. If the minimum number of participants is not met and the operator cancels, you will be offered another date or experience, or a full refund.
Should you book the Orkney Mainland Private Tour?
Book it if you want a well-covered introduction to Orkney Mainland, a private vehicle, and a guide who adds local character to the famous sites. The strongest reasons are Paul’s warm approach, the included Skara Brae and Italian Chapel fees, and the chance to see places that are awkward to combine without your own transport.
Think twice if the $322.21 price feels high, you want full control over each stop, or Brough of Birsay is essential and your schedule cannot handle a tide-related change. For everyone else, this is a packed but sensible day that links Orkney’s most important historic sights without making you do the logistical work yourself.
FAQ
How long does the Orkney Mainland Private Tour last?
The tour lasts approximately seven hours. About two hours are set aside for travel between the different sites.
Where does the tour start and end?
The stated meeting point is Kirkwall Hotel in Kirkwall, Orkney, postcode KW15 1LE. The tour ends back at the meeting point.
Is pickup available from other locations?
Yes. Pickup can be arranged from many other places on Orkney Mainland. You should provide your preferred pickup point when making arrangements.
Is lunch included?
No. Lunch is not included, but the tour allows time to stop at a local eatery. A typical lunch costs around $10 to $20.
Is admission to Skara Brae included?
Yes. The Skara Brae entrance fee of £12 per person is included in the tour price.
Is the Italian Chapel entrance included?
Yes. The Italian Chapel entrance fee of £3.50 per person is included.
Can I visit Brough of Birsay at any time?
Access to Brough of Birsay depends on tidal times because you cross a causeway at low tide. The operator will advise you about the timing, and the route may be adjusted if necessary.
Just added around Scotland
- Escape Burns’ Hame Toun: Outdoor Puzzle Game in Ayr★ 4.5 · 3 reviews
- Hebridean Whisky Tasting Experience★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Isle of Skye transfer to Inverness★ 4.5 · 3 reviews
- Private Balmoral Glamis Dunnottar Castles Tour from Aberdeen★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Glasgow: Glencoe & Oban Privately Guided Day Tour in Luxury MPV★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Shore Excursion: Private Braveheart & Whisky country from Edinburgh★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Highland Lochs & Castles Tour to Oban & Glencoe★ 5.0 · 3 reviews
- Jacobites and Scottish Highlands Day Tour from Glasgow★ 4.5 · 3 reviews
Orkney & Shetland Tours, compared.

5-Day Orkney & Northern Coast Tour from Edinburgh Incl Admissions
Read our review →
8 Day Isle of Skye, Orkney & North Coast 500 tour from Edinburgh
Read our review →
3-Day Orkney Explorer Small-Group Tour from Inverness
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in





